The ultimate guide to vendor management KPIs: Everything you need to know (2024)

Vendor management helps businesses enhance their budget allocation and increase profitability. Despite the complexity of the process, you can navigate this challenge effectively with vendor management KPIs. 

According to recent estimates, 68% of business leaders identify SaaS spend optimization as their most significant area of improvement. In this context, vendor management KPIs reflect the state of vendor relationships in real time by constantly measuring their performance against specific goalposts.

In this article, we’ll explore why these KPIs matter in today’s business world. Also, to help you leverage this in no time, we have curated a list of the top 10 important vendor management KPIs. 

Importance of vendor management KPIs 

Before we get into the specifics of vendor management KPIs, consider this scenario:

As a procurement manager, your operations heavily rely on third-party tools, and part of your role involves monitoring vendor KPIs. Now, imagine a situation where one provider consistently raises subscription costs, impacting profit margins.

By leveraging insights from these KPIs that quickly reveal the escalating costs, you can swiftly respond by renegotiating existing terms or exploring alternative providers. 

The outcome: controlled expenses, improved margins, and enhanced scalability.

Tracking vendors' KPIs enables companies to identify strengths and weaknesses in their vendor relationships, facilitating informed decision-making and strategic improvements. 

To sum up, vendor management KPIs in the SaaS domain ensure:

• Strict cost control and budget adherence
• Monitoring subscription cost fluctuations and their impact on profit margins
• Swift action when a vendor's service quality declines or costs surge
• Better scalability and profitability
• Financial health and driving growth in SaaS ventures.

10 vendor management KPIs you need to track

Here is the list of the top 10 vendor management KPIs you need to track for cost savings.

1. Return on investment 
2. Compliance rate
3. Supplier lead time
4. Support ticket resolution time
5. Product/service defect rate
6. Order accuracy
7. Order capacity
8. Competitiveness
9. Risk assessment
10. Innovation

1. Return on investment (ROI)

The calculation of ROI helps evaluate how a SaaS tool contributes to revenue growth, cost savings, and overall business performance over a specific period. You can also gauge the effectiveness of the technology investment and make informed decisions regarding its continuation or potential replacement.

To measure ROI, calculate the cost of implementing and maintaining the SaaS platform against the benefits it generates. This includes not only direct financial gains but also factors like: 

• Increased productivity
• Reduced operational costs
• Enhanced customer satisfaction

People-centric HR tech BetterPlace achieved 4x ROI within a month by streamlining SaaS buying with Spendflo. Read the full case study here.

2. Compliance rate

This vendor performance management KPI tracks the extent to which a vendor aligns with predetermined criteria, encompassing data security protocols, service level agreements (SLAs), privacy regulations, and contractual obligations. 

A comprehensive compliance rate KPI not only safeguards against legal repercussions but also reinforces trust in vendor reliability, contributing to sustained operational continuity and bolstered financial stability within the organization.

Maintaining a high compliance rate with SaaS vendors is crucial for mitigating risks and ensuring regulatory adherence. Evaluating compliance often involves: 

• Regular audits
• Performance assessments
• Robust reporting mechanisms

Recommended read: Understanding vendor compliance and its importance in SaaS businesses

3. Supplier lead time

Supplier lead time refers to the duration between placing an order with a SaaS vendor and receiving the service or product. This KPI for vendor management directly impacts cost management strategies by influencing inventory levels and project execution schedules. 

A shorter lead time often correlates with enhanced agility, reduced inventory carrying costs, and improved responsiveness to changing business needs. By tracking supplier lead time meticulously, CFOs can strategically: 

• Streamline procurement processes
• Negotiate better terms with vendors
• Align resource allocation in tandem with business demands

4. Support ticket resolution time

Support ticket resolution time measures the time taken to address and resolve customer-reported issues or queries related to the SaaS product or service. For CFOs, this KPI signifies the efficiency of vendor support services and directly impacts customer satisfaction and operational productivity. 

A shorter resolution time indicates efficient support processes, improved user experience, and heightened customer satisfaction. However, longer resolution times can lead to increased downtime, affecting productivity and potentially harming the company's reputation. 

By setting benchmarks for acceptable resolution times and consistently monitoring this KPI, you can ensure that vendors meet SLAs and maintain high standards of support.  

5. Product/service defect rate

Product/service defect rate signifies the frequency or percentage of defects, errors, or bugs identified in the SaaS product or service provided by a vendor. It assesses the quality and reliability of the technology implemented.

To measure this KPI, track the number of identified defects within a specific period and divide it by the total units of product or service consumed or utilized during that time frame. Multiply the result by 100 to obtain the defect rate percentage.

Monitoring this KPI for vendor management enables you to evaluate the reliability of the SaaS solution. Lower defect rates indicate higher quality and reduced support costs.

6. Order accuracy

Order accuracy evaluates the precision of orders fulfilled by vendors concerning the correctness of items, quantities, specifications, and delivery details compared to what was requested by the purchasing company.

To measure order accuracy, compare the details of orders received from vendors against the requested specifications and quantities. Calculate the percentage of accurately fulfilled orders.

Tracking order accuracy allows you to assess the vendor's reliability and efficiency in meeting the company's requirements. High order accuracy translates to reduced operational errors, minimized returns, and optimized inventory management.

For example, if a company orders 100 software licenses with specific features and receives exactly 100 licenses meeting all specifications, the order accuracy rate is 100%. Consistently monitoring this KPI for vendor management helps ensure vendors consistently meet order requirements, optimizing operational efficiency.

7. Order capacity

Order capacity measures a vendor's capability to handle the volume and scale of orders the purchasing company requests within a given timeframe.

To measure this KPI for vendor management, evaluate the vendor's historical performance in meeting order demands. Assess the number of orders fulfilled within specified timelines against the total orders placed.

Suppose, the company places 100 orders and the vendor delivers 90 of those within the stipulated time, the order capacity rate is 90%. 

Monitoring order capacity allows CFOs to anticipate the vendor's ability to scale alongside the company's growth. It aids in ensuring timely deliveries, mitigating bottlenecks, and avoiding disruptions due to vendor limitations.

8. Competitiveness

Competitiveness measures a vendor's position in the market concerning its offerings, pricing, innovation, and market share compared to other vendors in the same domain. 

To measure this KPI, analyze market reports, conduct vendor assessments, and compare the vendor's strengths, weaknesses, pricing models, and innovation against direct competitors.

If vendor A consistently introduces innovative features, maintains competitive pricing, and captures a significant market share compared to its competitors, it demonstrates high competitiveness.

Tracking this KPI for vendor management helps CFOs understand the vendor's market standing, allowing informed decisions on vendor selection, vendor negotiation, and strategic partnerships. Remember, a competitive vendor often offers better services, pricing, and innovative solutions, benefiting the company.

9. Risk assessment

Risk assessment evaluates the potential threats, vulnerabilities, and impact posed by a vendor's services or products on the company's operations, finances, security, and compliance.

To measure risk assessment, conduct thorough assessments of vendor security protocols, financial stability, compliance adherence, and track record. Use risk matrices to categorize and quantify risks associated with vendor relationships.

Monitoring risk assessment allows CFOs to mitigate potential disruptions, financial losses, and compliance issues caused by vendor-related risks. It assists leaders in making informed decisions regarding vendor partnerships, ensuring business continuity and security.

For instance, a SaaS vendor with a history of security breaches poses a higher risk to a company's data integrity. Through detailed assessments, CFOs can identify such risks and take proactive measures like implementing additional security protocols or seeking alternative vendors to safeguard the company's interests.

Recommended read: Vendor Assessment: Why & How to do Risk Assessment Audit

10. Innovation

Innovation as a vendor management KPI assesses a vendor's ability to introduce new, cutting-edge features, technologies, or methodologies that bring added value, efficiency, or competitive advantages to the company. 

For instance, a vendor adding automated reporting features to their analytics tool may demonstrate innovation. To measure this KPI for vendor management, evaluate the vendor's track record in introducing new features, updates, or advancements to their SaaS product. 

One of vendor performance management best practices is to consider the impact and relevance of these innovations to the company's needs and industry trends. Innovative vendors often provide solutions that enhance efficiency, drive revenue, and maintain a competitive edge.

Streamline vendor performance management using Spendflo

Simplify vendor management and amplify your SaaS strategy with Spendflo's comprehensive platform for a more profitable and streamlined operation.

As a comprehensive digital procurement and management platform, Spendflo simplifies SaaS stack optimization with benchmarking data and negotiation expertise for streamlined operations. 

Its intuitive interface consolidates vendor contracts, tracking SaaS renewals and security changes, while AI-powered contract management expedites processes. 

With vendor management, businesses can tap into Spendflo’s powerful platform, benchmarking data and negotiating expertise to streamline their SaaS stack.

Want to see how much you can save? 

‍Get a free savings analysis with us today!